| Kris Andoos** Marc Babich Stephen Bendel* Dave Bettes* Matty Bettes Mikey Bettes Tommy Bettes Jr.** Danny Brandi John Buckman Jimmy Calderone Vinny Calderone* Fr. Chris Costigan Kevin Costigan** Ryan Costigan Sean Costigan* Timmy Costigan Robert DePhillips* Robert Devlin Dave Duignan |
Deacon Jim Flannery** Charlie Fortin*** Gil Frank* Matt Frankel* Dominick Giampolo** Kevin Grasing Paul Grim* Todd Grim* Anton Heinlein* Ralph LaGuardia Jr.* Dominic Lagudi III Keith Lane Matt Martin Joe Majid Anthony McCarty*** Tommy McDermott** Robert Moyer Gary Mulcahy* Paul Napoli** Steven Napoli |
Robert Pav Robbie Pav Jr. Bruce Phelan Kevin Rahn Sean Regan Tommy Regan* Lenny Rossello Richard Schroder* Jay Schwartz Artie Seaman * Mike Selover Billy Sitzman Mike Sloan Sr.* Mike Sloan Jr. Juilan Tavalaro Sr. * Robert Valentine Randee Watson Jonathan Weiss |
| Key: ****Chief Proby *Ex-Captian **Ex-Chief ***Commissioner |